Place cheese on both slices of bread, topping cheese with fillings as desired. Close the sandwich and spread mayonnaise evenly on both sides of sandwich.
Place crisper plate in the Small Batch Container, then place sandwich on plate.
Attach CRISPi PowerPod to container, press MODE until AIR FRY illuminates, set time to 8 minutes, and press START to begin cooking.
When 5 minutes remain on the timer, remove PowerPod and use a nonstick spatula to gently flip sandwich. Replace PowerPod and press START to resume cooking.
When cooking is complete, cut grilled cheese in half and serve immediately.
